Just recently tried some. Surprising good. Like the high fiber too. Just got the last 2 catalina crunches I hadn't tried.

Also got a special k kind the other day. Less fiber, but the best tasting of all of them. Least affordable option at like over a dollar per ounce.



Anyone try one not pictured here that you would recommend?

9/18/2025 4:55:22 PM

I sometimes get paid to eat Catalina Crunch by NCSU

9/19/2025 9:14:06 AM

I wouldn't eat only the protein cereals, but they are a break from daily morning carb-city.

Never got those brands tho.

9/19/2025 3:04:03 PM

^which ones do you eat?

^^ nice. I'm jelly.

9/19/2025 4:47:13 PM

We bought some Catalina crunch and found it inedible

Ended up throwing away most of the starter kit

I like my cereal warmed up and it just became very slimy

9/19/2025 5:03:10 PM

Wtf is a starter kit? Google has nothing. Maybe try eating it normally? Probably didn't even use dairy milk

9/19/2025 6:36:36 PM

It was just like a sampling of like 6 different flavors

It was regular dairy milk…

9/19/2025 6:39:07 PM

Interesting

Don't really care for the honey nut & almond, pumpkin spice, or maple waffle, but I found them all quite edible. Costco sells a big bag(pictured) that is by far the most affordable(12.69 for 1.5lbs)

9/19/2025 6:51:01 PM

Released 2 new flavors today, picked them up to try, but small bags just no practical long term.

3 most economical options

1st best - costco, 24oz cinnamon 12.69
2nd best- sams, 22oz cinnamon 11.99
3rd best- sams online only 19oz blueberry 11.99




Soon will have tried all 13

Their snack mix real good too, i got the spicy snack mix and it is superb

12/2/2025 1:03:38 AM

12/2/2025 9:04:37 AM

like I hinted at above, I had a bunch of those cereals at the NCSU "Sensory Service Center" aka the Taste Test lab several years ago

on Thurs I'm having vanilla almond granola

12/2/2025 9:13:41 AM

Have you tried the 2 new flavors(apple turnover, strawberry strudel) before?

12/2/2025 9:31:43 AM

Just to update, they changed recipe starting about 3 months ago. Can still find old stock at some of the sams, but even those are scarce now. Costco had 24oz bags of new stock for 7.69 or so, limit 10. Got the limit, noticed the change in macros and taste, and returned the 9 i hadn't opened. All the reviews on the site mention the change

https://us.catalinacrunch.com/products/cinnamon-toast-cereal

Was good while it lasted, but totally done with them now

5/21/2026 9:55:11 PM